2010年1月31日星期日

Puluo

Last week I commented on Elaine's and Sonia's reflections.
P.S. Because of some technical problems, I post my response to ST Forum on the comment of this thread...

1 条评论:

  1. IPs, Not That Necessary
    By Puluo
    http://www.straitstimes.com/STForum/OnlineStory/STIStory_483952.html
    The article is about IPs (integrated programme). According to Wikipedia (2009), ‘IP is a scheme which allows the brightest pupils at secondary schools in Singapore to bypass O levels and take the A levels’. The writer advocates that IPs should be restricted for following reasons. First, she claims that it is easier for students in normal secondary schools to perform well in O levels because of less competition, resulting in excellent O-level score to be not representative to some extent. Second, because of special management in IP schools, IP students have less interaction with other people, which may hinder their psychological growth.
    In my opinion, IP is not necessary, and I do not support building IP schools. The news reminds me of my high school in China. The school is one of the best schools in my city, and it is made up of junior high school and senior high school. It has once make a programme for the excellent students in its junior high school to enter its senior high school without attending the senior high school entrance exam, an authorized and important exam. Unlike Singapore, where the IP students have more time to do other activities rather than just study, the chosen ones in my school were forced to learn much more advanced. As a result, most of them could not keep with the step and even fell behind. Moreover, similarly to Singapore, they communicated with fewer people and they had a smaller group of friends since their schedule was different. Eventually, the programme was only carried out for one batch for not achieving the expectation – to make excellent students more all-rounded. I do not know much about IP in Singapore, but after reading the article, I quite agree with the author’s points. In addition, I don't think IP is important for one main reason. The mainstream for students to enter college in Singapore is attending O levels and then A levels. These two exams are not only for them to prove their academic performance, but also to help them build the mind of cruel competition in the real life. Because of special treatment for the IP students, most of them may feel less competitive and know the real cruel situation than normal students. Consequently, their talent may not be transformed to their advantages, and they may even not keep in path with normal students. I support that secondary schools can set some experimental classes for those top students to study and attend activities differently from other normal students, but those students should also take the O levels exam. In conclusion, I don't think IP very necessary, and I suggest that all students should attend the O levels so that they can keep competitive.

    回复删除